I have this marked as being in Scott county, but some of the other websites I've seen have it as in Jennings county. This pay lake is open, and they are catching fish. Did you try to call them ? My information came from the owner of Catfish Charlie's pay lake.
The Kimberly Lake can be found on the Deputy USGS quad topo map. Kimberly Lake is a reservoir in Jennings County in the state of Indiana. The latitude and longitude coordinates for this reservoir are 38.8464, -85.6475 and the altitude is 669 feet (204 meters).
Feature Type: Reservoir
Elevation: 669 ft (204 m)
Kimberly Lake is located at 9410 S County Road 200 W, Commiskey, IN and can be contacted at (812) 346-5756.